Carpaccio – Painter first, Dish second

Steven, a dear friend and mentor, asked me about carpaccio over the weekend.  He’d had some vegetables sliced finely, dressed and listed as a ’carpaccio’.  Nothing too wrong with that, asuming they tasted good and the dish was well executed, but it does raise a bigger point and one worth a post.

More than ever today, there are chefs in the habit of using culinary descriptors which have only the loosest connection to the original dish.  Any grain resembling rice can become a ‘risotto’, a dish where meat or anything much else is long cooked in white beans is a ‘cassoulet’, a ‘pilaff’ becomes a ‘paella’ - and the most tasteless of intensively reared chicken, stewed off in some indifferent red wine is graced with the title ‘Coq au Vin’.


Cockerels are impossible to find in English supermarkets.  They are standard fare in  French – they’re usually cut into portions and the meat is pinkish in colour – not too attractive. The closest you can get is boiling fowl in the street markets in England - this is a ‘spent’ laying bird, but it’s a poor cousin to a pure bred, proud cockerel who’s spent a lifetime playing out his role as Chanticleer.

At little more than one month old, a broiler chicken hasn’t reached puberty and, to save money, won’t have been sexed anyway – what’s the point because they’ll be breaded and fried before they ever get to do what Nature intended to continue the line.

Without labouring the point – ‘Coq’ means cockerel. He’s a spent male and tough as they come.  The dish originates in Burgundy where the red wine is made only from the Pinot Noir grape.  Long cooking of the brute makes for a fine, old fashioned farmhouse dish – better to eat him than give him a decent burial for all his efforts around the farmyard over the past 2-3 years.

Cooking – and haute cuisine – must evolve.  To take a technique and give it a smart twist can be good for that evolutionary process.  My beef is that the original is first not forgotten and second not besmerched by some aspiring catering college leaver who wouldn’t their know canoli from their canaroli from their cassoulet.

Carpaccio – painter first, dish second

Back to carpaccio – the dish has an inventive start.  It was created – for ‘created’ it was – by Arrigo Cipriani’s father in 1950 for a titled Harry’s Bar regular whose doctor had forbade her to eat cooked meat.  Sirloin of aged beef was sliced as thin as airmail paper, arranged on a plate and artfully criss-crossed with a special off-white dressing.  Jackson Pollock’s wonderful paint drizzling technique comes to mind – and to think Jackson himself was across the Grand Canal at this very time hanging out with Peggy Guggenheim and her cronies, too poor to drink at Harry’s. What a collaboration that could have been.

The big art show on in Venice at the time was of Vittore Carpaccio, the Italian Renaissance painter who is famous for his vivid reds and whites. Cipriani Senior called his creation Carpaccio for just that reason.

So, our carpaccio is rooted in a bar-room snack.  New wave Italian chefs love to use it for raw fish – we ate some of the best in Portovenere on my partner Joy’s birthday – it was February, the sky was blue and the sun was shining.  We had the restaurant to ourselves, meaning we had the kitchen to ourselves so asked chef for a long, slow degustation – dish upon dish of exquisite carpacccio’s of fish came to the table, mostly finely sliced, some escabeche, followed by ‘carpaccio’d’ vegetables and meat. Nothing was cooked. The only hot food was the ristretto.

So evolution is a good thing.  Coarse cut sausages cooked in canned white beans does not a cassoulet make however.  The BBC’s tedious Saturday Kitchen has an endless list of faux-recettes. They’d be sort of funny if the chefs weren’t so serious about their inventions.  Faites-bien attention mes Cols Bleu’s.

This entry was posted in Blue Collar Gastronomy, Fish, Food Influencers, Food travel, Great Chefs, Kitchen Tips, Latest Trends, Risotto, Techniques and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Carpaccio – Painter first, Dish second

  1. Beautiful blog! Just lovely!

    • Gareth says:

      Photo coming up shortly too. Thanks for your comments. Find time to scroll back through the 100 or so posts I’ve made since my time in Bresse to celebrate Les Glorieuses last December.


  2. Jay Sames says:

    Agreed. I learned something. Then something more. And finally I walked away with an opinion on something about which I never knew enough to even have an opinion.


  3. Great information. Thanks for submitting this. I will check back to see what other information you post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>